The Ultimate Guide to Boosting Email Marketing ROI with Cold Emails
Connor Addis

Reading time: 12 min


Share:

The Ultimate Guide to Boosting Email Marketing ROI with Cold Emails

The Ultimate Guide to Boosting Email Marketing ROI with Cold Emails preview

We all know how crucial email marketing is for businesses, but have you ever wondered how to really make it work for you? Well, I'm here to tell you that the secret sauce lies in mastering email marketing ROI, especially when it comes to cold emails. It's not just about sending out messages; it's about creating connections that lead to real results and boost your bottom line. That's why I'm excited to dive into this topic with you today.

In this guide, we'll explore the ins and outs of email marketing ROI and how cold emails can be a game-changer for your revenue generation efforts. We'll look at the key metrics you need to keep an eye on to measure success, and I'll share some killer strategies to help you boost your return on investment. From personalization techniques to crafting compelling subject lines, we'll cover everything you need to know to take your email marketing to the next level. So, let's get started and unlock the potential of your email campaigns!

Understanding Email Marketing ROI

When it comes to email marketing, understanding ROI is crucial for success. Let's dive into what it means and why it's so important, especially for cold emails.

What is Email Marketing ROI?

Email marketing ROI is all about the profit we get after covering the costs of our email campaigns . It's like a report card for our marketing efforts, showing us how well we're doing. The basic formula is pretty simple: (Total revenue - Total cost) / Total cost . But don't let that fool you – getting accurate numbers can be tricky!

To really get a handle on our ROI, we need to keep an eye on some key metrics. These include:

  1. Conversion rate: This tells us how many people took the action we wanted after opening our email.
  2. Click-through rate: This shows how many folks clicked on links in our email.
  3. List-growth rate: This helps us track how our subscriber list is growing (or shrinking).
  4. Forward/share rate: This lets us know if people are spreading our message.
  5. Bounce rate: This tells us how many emails didn't make it to inboxes.
  6. Unsubscribe rate: This shows how many people decided to opt out .

Why ROI Matters for Cold Emails

Now, you might be wondering, "Why should I care about ROI for cold emails?" Well, let me tell you, it's super important! Here's why:

  1. It's our compass for success: By keeping track of our ROI, we can see what's working and what's not. This way, we can make smart decisions about where to put our time and money .
  2. It helps us make budget decisions: If one campaign is giving us better returns than another, we know where to invest more .
  3. It shows the power of email: Did you know that for every GBP 0.79 spent on email marketing, the average return is GBP 33.00? That's pretty amazing!
  4. It guides our strategy: ROI isn't set in stone. By measuring it regularly, we can tweak our approach for even better results .

Common ROI Calculation Methods

Now, let's talk about how we can actually calculate our ROI. There are a couple of ways to go about this:

  1. The Cost-Based Method:This method involves looking at all our costs and comparing them to our results. Here's a quick breakdown:
    • Step 1: Figure out how much we're spending on our team (like Sales Development Representatives).
    • Step 2: Add up the costs of our email marketing tools.
    • Step 3: Calculate our total investment.
    • Step 4: Look at how many leads and sales opportunities we've generated.
    • Step 5: Calculate our revenue and profit.
    • Step 6: Use the ROI formula to get our final number .
  2. The CRM-Based Method:This approach starts with getting our Customer Relationship Management (CRM) tracking in order. Here's what we do:

Remember, the key to accurate ROI calculation is having good data. Many companies struggle with this because of missing historical data, unclear costs, inaccurate pipeline data, or faulty tracking systems .

By understanding and regularly calculating our email marketing ROI, we can make sure we're getting the most bang for our buck. It's not just about sending emails; it's about creating connections that lead to real results and boost our bottom line. So, let's keep tracking, analyzing, and optimizing for success!

Key Metrics to Track for Cold Email Success

When it comes to cold email campaigns, tracking the right metrics is crucial to understand how well we're doing and where we can improve. Let's dive into some key metrics that can help us boost our email marketing ROI.

Open Rates

Open rates are like our first impression – they tell us how many people are actually opening our emails. It's pretty simple to calculate: just divide the number of opened emails by the number of delivered emails (excluding bounces) . While the average open rate across all industries is about 21%, for cold emails, we're looking at a more realistic range of 15-25% . If we're hitting these numbers or higher, we're on the right track!

But here's the thing – open rates aren't everything. They can be a bit misleading due to technical issues . Plus, with recent privacy updates, they might not be as reliable for measuring email deliverability as they used to be . Still, they're useful to get a general idea of how our subject lines are performing and if we're landing in inboxes or spam folders .

Click-Through Rates (CTR)

Next up, we've got click-through rates. This is the percentage of people who click on a link in our email . The formula is simple: (number of clicks / number of impressions) x 100% . Now, don't get discouraged if these numbers seem low – the average CTR for cold emails is just 3.67% . That means for every 100 emails we send, we might get about 3 or 4 clicks. It might not sound like much, but it's actually pretty good for cold outreach!

To boost our CTR, we need to make sure we're targeting the right people. Sending emails to folks who match our ideal customer profile can make a big difference . Also, personalization is key – studies show that personalized emails get 41% more unique clicks than generic ones .

Conversion Rates

Now, let's talk about conversion rates. This is where the rubber meets the road – it's the percentage of email recipients who complete the action we want them to take, like signing up for a demo or making a purchase . According to recent data, the average cold email conversion rate is around 8.5% . But remember, this can vary a lot depending on our industry and what we're offering.

To improve our conversion rates, we need to focus on a few things:

  1. Have a clear call-to-action (CTA) so people know exactly what we want them to do.
  2. Make sure our landing page is top-notch – it should be compelling and free from distractions .
  3. Offer something valuable that our prospects actually want or need.

Response Rates

Last but definitely not least, we've got response rates. This is the number of people who reply to our emails . It's a strong indicator of engagement – much more so than open rates. While a good open rate is nice, what we really want is for people to hit that reply button!

According to some studies, if we send a sequence of three messages, we can expect almost 3 times more replies than if we just send one . That's why follow-ups are so important. We shouldn't put all our hopes on that first email – it's often the follow-ups that get the response .

A healthy reply rate for cold emails ranges from 1% to 3% . But don't worry if we're on the lower end – cold emailing is a numbers game, and even a 1% reply rate can lead to significant leads if our email list is large enough .

Remember, these metrics work together to give us a full picture of our cold email performance. By keeping an eye on all of them and continuously tweaking our approach, we can boost our email marketing ROI and see real results from our cold email campaigns.

Strategies to Boost Cold Email ROI

Let's dive into some powerful strategies to boost our cold email ROI. We'll explore personalization techniques, A/B testing subject lines, optimizing send times, and following up effectively. These tactics will help us get more out of our email marketing efforts and improve our return on investment.

Personalization Techniques

Personalization is a game-changer when it comes to cold emails. It shows our prospects that we've done our homework and care about catching their attention. In fact, one in three marketers in the US and UK use email subject line personalization in their campaigns . Here are some effective personalization techniques we can use:

  1. Use the recipient's name in the subject line and email body
  2. Mention specific details about their industry or interests
  3. Reference recent achievements or developments in their company
  4. Highlight mutual connections or interests
  5. Address specific pain points or goals

By personalizing our emails, we can increase engagement metrics across the board. It's not just about using merge tags; it's about creating a connection that resonates with our prospects.

A/B Testing Subject Lines

A/B testing, or split testing, is crucial for optimizing our subject lines. It involves creating two versions of our email and sending them to different segments of our list to see which performs better. Here are some ideas for A/B testing subject lines:

  1. Test subject line length (short vs. long)
  2. Try using lowercase vs. title case
  3. Include or exclude the prospect's name
  4. Use emojis vs. no emojis
  5. Ask a question vs. make a statement

Remember, 82% of marketers send emails with subject lines of 60 characters or less . This is because most emails are read on mobile devices, where long subject lines get truncated.

Optimizing Send Times

Timing is everything when it comes to cold emails. Let's look at some data on the best times to send:

  • Brevo reported that 85% of all email opens and 95% of all clicks happen on weekdays .
  • Tuesday and Thursday account for the greatest share of opens, at 19% and 20% respectively .
  • Wednesdays have the most click-throughs at 35% .
  • GetResponse found that weekday open rates are consistently over 26%, with Tuesdays having a slight edge at 27.5% .

However, our research of over 85,000 personalized emails shows that the best time to send cold emails is between 6-9am PST on Monday, with Tuesday as a close second . To take advantage of the two-hour spike in open and click rates, we recommend scheduling delivery between 7-8 am PST .

Following Up Effectively

Following up is crucial for boosting our cold email ROI. In fact, even one follow-up email can increase our reply rate by 22% . Here are some tips for effective follow-ups:

  1. Keep it short and simple
  2. Make it easy to respond to
  3. Keep it coherent with the previous message
  4. Maintain a natural tone
  5. Provide additional value in each follow-up

As for timing, it's best to wait 1-3 days before sending the first follow-up. The optimal number of follow-ups seems to be 2 or 3 . Here's a suggested sequence:

  • Day 1: Initial email
  • Day 3: First follow-up
  • Day 7: Second follow-up

By implementing these strategies, we can significantly boost our cold email ROI. Remember, it's all about personalization, testing, timing, and persistence. Let's put these tactics into action and watch our email marketing success soar!

Conclusion

To wrap up, mastering cold email marketing can significantly boost your ROI and take your business to new heights. By focusing on key metrics like open rates, click-through rates, and conversion rates, you can fine-tune your approach and see real results. Remember, it's all about creating connections that lead to meaningful interactions and, ultimately, boost your bottom line.

Implementing strategies like personalization, A/B testing, and optimizing send times can make a world of difference in your email campaigns. Don't forget the power of follow-ups – they're often the key to turning a cold lead into a warm prospect. By putting these tactics into action and consistently refining your approach, you'll be well on your way to email marketing success. So go ahead, give these strategies a try, and watch your cold email ROI soar!

FAQs

What is the typical response rate for cold emails?The average response rate for cold emails is about 8.5%. This rate can decrease if fewer people open the emails, as noted in research by Backlinko.

What return on investment does email marketing typically achieve?Email marketing can yield a return on investment of approximately 4,200%, where for every GBP 0.79 spent, marketers may earn around GBP 33.00. This high ROI, which varies by industry, underscores why email marketing is highly valued.

How effective is cold email marketing as a strategy?Cold email marketing is considered highly effective by professionals, with 23% of sales experts identifying it as the top method for initiating contact with prospects. Additionally, 21% of salespeople report that it generates the most leads, offering a cost-effective alternative to other lead generation methods.

What is considered a satisfactory ROI for an email marketing campaign?A good benchmark for email marketing ROI is between GBP 28.28 to GBP 31.43 for every dollar spent, based on various studies. This range provides a target for marketers to aim for when assessing the success of their email campaigns.



The number one UK B2B appointment setting agency

Book your demo

Related articles

Still unsure?

Submit your email to receive a video replay of a demo plus latest news from the Lead Gen Department.